Friday, April 01, 2011

Journalism Excellence? No.

I regularly think up topics or come across news articles I decide I should address or respond to on this blog, but I obviously rarely get around to it. But today I just had to show you this article from Wednesday’s USA Today. Some of the relevant text is pasted below in case the link goes bad some day. See if you can see the fallacy. I will explain below the jump.

“[A] USA TODAY analysis has determined that a typical player for a program receives at least $120,000 annually in goods, services and future earnings for his athletic work.”

“But more than scholarships, players receive benefits including: elite coaching; academic counseling; strength and conditioning consulting; media relations assistance; medical insurance and treatment; free game tickets; and future earnings power that comes with some college education.” (Weiner & Berkowitz, USA Today, 3/30/2011)

The article was pretty interesting, but I am pretty disappointed in the “USA TODAY analysis” as well as the authors of the article. The problem is that by counting scholarships for tuition and future earnings power separately they are double counting. It is a pretty glaring error in logic. The value of the latter is the biggest reason for the value of the former. The analogy would be if I give you an apple that would have cost 50 cents. Then I tell you that what I gave you was worth $1.00: 50 cents for the apple, and 50 cents of your own money that you don’t have to pay to get the apple. It doesn't work.


almwso3a said...

Come here from egypt said...

lin The third stop, are coach bags Blue came to Shanghai, filmmaker Steven David Lynch and Klein let that Chinese and western blends Cotillard in this city has played a heart-breaking Coach Wedges past life's love story: at the COACH BOOTS beginning of the story, the heroine after a long hotel corridor, full of suspense flavor. When Coach Backpack Bags Cotillard just entered the room, shortly after a Coach Backpack Bags smoke behind her raise, smoke dispersed, leaving a are Dior Coach Carly Bags coach bags. A panic, Cotillard recall past lover, and Coach Claire Bags had him lover will are Blue as the only trust, for Coach Ergo Bags a period of no ending love leave footnote. The Coach Garnet Bags reality and illusion of crisscross story, let a person lady-g Cotillard handsome charming face present before our eyes. That face amaze the stadium. When the play ended, drop-dead gorgeous carry elegant Dior coach bags are slowly down the steps, youth coach outlet online budding is the illustrator frenzy, elderly disabled old man even on their own strength to stand

Bloggzilla said...

The kid who begging for money in the comments is a genius.

chanel668 said...

cheap sunglasses
designer sunglasses

Sunglasses 2011
Adidas Sunglasses
Anarchy Sunglasses
Arnette Sunglasses
Brighton Sunglasses
Cartier Sunglasses
Chopper Sunglasses
Coach Sunglasses
Diamond Eyewear Sunglasses
Diesel Sunglasses
D&G Sunglasses
Ed Hardy Sunglasses
Gargoyles Sunglasses
Guess Sunglasses
Harley Sunglasses
Kenneth Cole Sunglasses
Liz Claiborne Sunglasses
Miu Miu Sunglasses
Nike Sunglasses
Prada Sunglasses
Ray Ban Sunglasses
Roxy Sunglasses
Smith Sunglasses
Valentino Sunglasses
Vogue Sunglasses
Aviator Sunglasses
Cat Eye Sunglasses
Oversized Sunglasses
Rectangular Sunglasses
Round Sunglasses
Shield Sunglasses
Square Sunglasses
Wrap Around Sunglasses

hapi said...

Hi Nick, Nice blog! How to add the Glitter Effect Mouse Pointer to your Blog

zhang1 said...

Abercrombie Fitch Clothing
Abercrombie Fitch sale
Abercrombie Fitch outlet

Abercrombie Womens
Abercrombie Womens Long Sleeve Tees
Abercrombie Womens Premium Sweaters
Abercrombie Womens Hoodies
Abercrombie Womens Classic Shirts
Abercrombie Womens Leather Thongs
Abercrombie Womens Classic Shorts
Abercrombie Womens Pants
Abercrombie Mens Plaid Shirts
Abercrombie Mens Vintage Polos
Abercrombie Mens Long Sleeve Tees
Abercrombie Mens Swim Short
Abercrombie Mens Classic Shirts
Abercrombie Mens Leather Thongs
Abercrombie Scarves
Abercrombie Jewellery said...

Do have pain,stress.pedress....Tony can hlep you! Please visit

wedding photography Melbourne said...

awesomely written must say

hoganshoesonsale said...

So what are artist shoes? They are typically linked with types which could be Franklin and Marshall clothing produced for

placing on with an evening gown or an business office outfit but they are not limited to just that. the north face saleArtist shoes can occur in just

about every type of design and you also may be astonished to know that you simply Belstaff Jackets Salecan purchase artist men's

shoes even although in the kind of sneakers that you simply can positioned on for frequent use. Buy Ugg Boots And regardless of the actuality

that artist women's shoes are regularly believed of as something strappy with large heels, you have women's artist

sneakers too.Babyliss Hair

Gucci shoes as well have instead a range or that you decide on from.

Jason2011 said...

Monster Beats

rscredits said...

buy rs gold by phone onebip or sms from Safe Store Rsorder a professional runescape gold seller. All cheap rs gold is transferred without cheats or hacks. rs gold can be supplied anytime. Fast in-game delivery within 10 minutes!cheapest runescape gold for you!

Mike Lee said...

Have you ever want to visit another galaxy or other planets? Have you ever want to see a werewolf, see vampire plants? Travel back in time, visit the moons of Jupiter, fight in a robot war, or ride a dragon? Then this is the book for you.

Earth’s end has arrived due to a man made virus and pollution of air, water and land. Even the Anti-Christ is desperate to get off the Earth before the end. A space lottery selects 200 brave souls to colonize a distant planet named Caldoria. Unfortunately, the ship pops out of its time/space warp and is severely damaged by a meteor shower. Oxygen is running out. All appears hopeless, or is it.
A Better Part of Heaven, by Mike Lee, now available for download from Amazon Kindle for only $2.99